Maligned and Misunderstood: Pit Bulls

helpemuppitbullAt Help ‘Em Up, our dog harnesses are often used on pit bulls who have lost their mobility or have hip dysplasia. These dogs are not the dangerous monsters often portrayed in the media. As a dog parent myself and as a business owner involved in the pet industry, I can tell you that pit bulls get a bad rap – in fact, all the breeds labeled as “bully breeds” do.

Pit bulls are usually a combination of American Pit Bull Terriers, American Staffordshire Terriers, Staffordshire Bull Terriers, Bull Terriers, and American Bulldogs. They have been misidentified as the “bully breeds” and are thought by many to be overly aggressive. Some of the most loyal and friendly dogs I have met and owned are pit bulls.

Here are some issues to test your knowledge of pit bulls:

Pit Bulls Are Dangerous
False. The American Temperament Test (see The American Temperament Society at shows that Pit Bulls consistently score above the average temperament for all breeds tested over the years. As of December 2007, American Pit Bull Terriers had a pass rate of 84.3 percent compared to a pass rate for all breeds tested of 81.6 percent. Contrary to popular opinion, pit bulls don’t have “locking jaws” that make them more vicious… c’mon they are pit bulls not alligators! There is nothing anatomically different about a pit bull’s jaws.

Pit Bulls Who Attack Other Dogs Will Attack Humans Too
Without a doubt, terriers are known for their energy and ability to be scrappy. A well- socialized pit bull who is not left alone all the time or raised to fight by unscrupulous owners is no more prone to bite a human than any other breed. If you are at a dog park, you will probably meet some friendly pit bulls and some not so friendly pit bulls. However, this will also hold true for Labradors and golden retrievers who are also known for their cuddliness and sweet temperament. It is more a function of nurture versus nature. How a dog is raised and trained will have more influence on any breed you will find more so than anything else. And there is no correlation between a pit bull showing aggression to another dog and then turning on a human.

Pit Bull Mixes Are Safer Than Pure Breds
. Some people believe that breeding a pure bred with a more mellow breed can dilute the aggression. This is not so. Although genetics is one component of a pit bull’s personality, upbringing, environment and management are even more influential.

Pit Bulls Shouldn’t Be Around Children
Ironically, for 114 years, pit bulls were known as “nanny dogs” by the United Kennel Club for their loyalty, friendly nature, and stability toward children. It wasn’t until 2007 when Atlanta Falcons quarterback Michael Vick pleaded guilty to running a dog-fighting operation that pit bulls drew media attention. Pit bulls can tolerate the rough and tumble play of children and usually greet them with tails wagging. As with any breed, children need to be taught how to interact with dogs and should not be left alone or unsupervised. Owning a dog is everyone’s responsibility.

Too many pit bulls are abused, neglected, abandoned and euthanized. They seem to be the “go to” dog for unethical breeders, dog fighters and people who just want to keep their dog chained up outside to look “tough”. Therefore, they end up in shelters in disproportionate numbers. Too often a trip to the shelter is a one way trip for pitties.

The ASPCA website sums it up best by saying: “A well-socialized and well-trained pit bull is one of the most delightful, intelligent, and gentle dogs imaginable.” The American Veterinary Association says “controlled studies have not identified this breed group as disproportionately dangerous.”

Like any breed of dog that we see in family homes today, a properly raised, well socialized, responsibly owned pit bull should never be aggressive towards other dogs or humans! And since it’s Adopt a Pet Month, consider a pit bull as your next family pet.

One thought on “Maligned and Misunderstood: Pit Bulls

  1. It’s only a fool hearty person that doesn’t realize the extra responsibility these bully breeds require. (You seem to take some offense to the term ‘bully breed’. What, if not this, would you prefer these breeds be referred to as?). These are strong, tenacious, formidable dogs requiring responsible, capable owners. There’s also not a reasonable person out there that doesn’t realize that, if in a fight with another dog, these dogs WILL win. One can debate these breeds’ gameness (predisposition to do what each breed is bred to do), but not that any breed is more equipped than the ‘Pitbull’ to win the fight. Dogs will fight, it’s the nature of the species. Pitbull owners must be vigilant about allowing their dogs to engage in confrontation and, if they are, what to do ABOUT it. There are any number of strategies for both but one cannot deny the harm a powerful Pitbull can inflict compared to all other breeds. This is the origin of this breed’s name: Right or wrong, this ‘breed’ was chosen among all other available breeds to fight, primarily other dogs, in fighting ‘pits’, often to the death. Again, like it or not, it’s fact. I would know … I come from a long line of ‘Pitbull’ breeders.

    A Pitbull owner MUST assess whether these are responsibilities they want to, or are capable of, assuming. Otherwise, they’re simply best choosing another breed. Again, I’m NOT commenting on whether Pitbulls do or don’t receive a ‘bad rap’, but only because they’re PERFECTLY EQUIPPED to inflict the greatest amount of harm by the most expedient means possible. Most dogs will grown, snap, and even get into an altercation with other dogs if needed. But, briefly or lengthy, once dominance is established between the dogs, they’ll back away from each other. Although your Pitbulls may be a cursory at home with you and your family, they’ll also protect you instinctually, ferociously, and they don’t loose the fight. Ever. For a Pit owner to refute this is fool hearty and irresponsible. It’s irresponsible of breeders, animal shelters, and rescue organizations to not qualify a potential dog owner before selling or placing a Pitbull. Similarly, it’s irresponsible of you to portray these dogs as simply having had a ‘bad rap’ or are simply ‘misunderstood’. Despite your experiences with these dogs, you should qualify your statements and acknowledge along with professionals’ (including the American Veterinary Medical Association and various Pitbull Registries) that this breed isn’t appropriate for everyone. It should also be made clear that landlords, Home Owners Associations, home insurance providers, even airlines have restrictions regarding these dogs and others.

    Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.